November 19, 2026
On the last two days of September, four Edgartown deeds went on record. Two were on Wilsons Lane, at $1,430,000 and $1,312,500. The other two were on Martha's Road at $1,900,000 and on Fifth Street North at $950,000. Together they came to about $5.6 million.
Two weeks later, the Vineyard Gazette's transaction column for the week ending October 16 listed five Edgartown sales. They were on Plantingfield Way at $17,500,000, Katama Bay View Road at $7,500,000, Somerset Lane at $6,400,000, South Water Street at $6,125,000 and Turkeyland Cove Road at $4,293,750. Those five deeds added up to about $41.8 million.
The headline averages are built mostly from weeks like the second one. A buyer with a $2 million budget will spend most of their search among homes like the first week's. In Edgartown the two have been moving in different directions for a while.
The MV Times 2025 market review counted 128 Edgartown transactions in 2025, against 129 in 2024 and 128 in 2023. Over the same years, dollar volume rose 11 percent from 2024 to 2025, reaching $398 million, and the average price rose 12 percent to $3.11 million. With the sale count flat, that growth came from the top of the market. Edgartown sales above $10 million doubled from three in 2024 to six in 2025. The town's largest 2025 sale was a $37.5 million harborfront home with a dock, the biggest transaction on the island that year.
The island's first half of 2026 followed the same pattern. The MV Times mid-year report put island-wide transactions for January through June 2026 at 148, down 5 percent from the first half of 2025. Dollar volume rose 23 percent to $375 million, and the average price of $2.53 million was the highest first-half figure on record. Over those six months, the island recorded six sales above $10 million, compared with one in the first half of 2025.
Then came Great Point, the Herring Creek Farm compound on Slough Cove. It sold this summer for $43 million after being listed at $49 million, and the MV Times reported it as a residential record for Massachusetts. The Vineyard Gazette reported the price as two deeds on Butlers Cove Road, at $27 million and $16 million. A single closing that size moves the town's average more than dozens of ordinary sales do.
The median sale price shows the typical home without the weight of the record compounds. The Massachusetts Association of Realtors' October 2026 Local Market Update for Edgartown covers single-family homes closed through that database, 40 of them from January through October 2026. Their median sale price was $2,412,500, down 5.2 percent from $2,545,000 over the same months of 2025.
That report covers a subset of the town's sales. The weekly deed columns show many more Edgartown closings than 40 a year. Still, it is the most recent town-level measure available, and it points the opposite way from the island averages. This year, averages hit records while the typical Edgartown home sold for slightly less.
Pace in that same subset improved. Homes that closed in 2026 through October spent a median of 78 days on market, down from 136 a year earlier, and sellers received 94.8 percent of their original list price, up from 89.6 percent. So homes are selling faster and closer to list, and the median price is still a little lower. Together, those numbers describe sellers who set realistic asking prices.
The 2025 review breaks Edgartown down by price band. Sales between $1 million and $3 million came to 70 in 2024 and 70 again in 2025. The $3 million to $10 million band fell from 41 sales to 35 over those years, and the $10 million-plus band doubled. The volume growth came from the top. The middle of the market produced the same number of sales two years in a row and none of the growth.
This fall's deeds show what that middle band buys, and where. The figures below come from the MV Times and Vineyard Gazette weekly transaction columns for early August through November 6, 2026.
| Price band | Edgartown sales on record, Aug. to early Nov. 2026 |
|---|---|
| Under $1 million | Boylston Drive, $435,000; Mill Street condominium, $495,000; Whalers Walk, $585,000; Third Street North, $699,000; Crocker Drive, $965,000 |
| $1 million to $3 million | Dodgers Hole Road, $1,050,000; Harbor View Avenue, $1,495,000; West Tisbury Road, $1,695,000; Chappaquiddick Road, $1,973,350; Oyster Pond Road, $2,100,000; Whalers Walk, $2,350,000; Atwood Circle, $2,588,000 and $2,850,000; Katama Point Road, $2,950,000; Kent Harbor Road, $2,950,000 |
| $3 million to $10 million | School Street, $3,600,000; High Street, $3,650,000; North Water Street, $4,400,000; Plain Field Way, $5,300,000; North Summer Street, $5,700,000; Katama Point Road, $6,400,000; Peases Point Way South, $8,175,000 |
| Over $10 million | Plantingfield Way, $17,500,000; Great Point on Butlers Cove Road, $43 million |
Location separates the bands more than size does. Most of the $3 million-plus sales cluster in the historic village on North Water, School, High and North Summer streets, or on the water at Katama Point. Among the village sales was the High Street house that was the former home of Clifford the Big Red Dog creator Norman Bridwell, reported by the MV Times at $3.65 million. The $1 million to $3 million band covers more ground. It runs along West Tisbury Road and the side streets off it, to Atwood Circle, Oyster Pond Road and Whalers Walk, and across the harbor to Chappaquiddick Road. Two sales on Katama Point Road show how sharp the line can be. One house there sold for $6.4 million on September 10, and another on the same road sold for $2.95 million on October 5.
The weekly columns show the fall's $3 million to $10 million activity running closer to the middle band than it did across 2025. That supports the same point. Edgartown's recent growth has come from the top of the market, and the averages report that growth as if it applied to every home in town.
The second difference between the bands is how buyers pay. The Vineyard Gazette reported in May that, according to the LINK database, 41 percent of island purchases from May 2025 through April 2026 were made in cash. On properties above $5 million, the share was 72 percent. The overall 41 percent includes those top-end sales, so cash buyers make up a smaller share of purchases below $5 million. The same article showed how much the cash share varies by town, from 67 percent in Chilmark to 27 percent in Oak Bluffs over that period.
LINK president Debra Taylor told the Gazette that cash still reaches lower price points, with investment buyers "buying something under $2 million, tearing the house down, and putting up a $5 million home." For a financed buyer in Edgartown's middle band, that is the likeliest competing offer. The Gazette also quoted Meryl Watson of Leader Bank on a full loan commitment issued before an offer. She said, "It's almost like a cash offer, because it can't fall apart, really. The only unknown is the appraisal."
The island-wide mid-year report includes a figure that the averages leave out. Of all properties sold on Martha's Vineyard in the first half of 2026, 75 percent closed below their asking price. Measured against all first-half sales, 29 percent closed 1 to 5 percent under asking, 31 percent closed 6 to 10 percent under, 12 percent closed 11 to 20 percent under, and 3 percent closed 21 to 33 percent under. Island inventory at mid-year 2026 was 288 properties, down from 350 at mid-year 2025.
For Edgartown specifically, the MAR October update shows the town's supply growing even as island inventory fell. It counted 43 single-family homes for sale in October 2026, against 34 a year earlier. It also recorded 100 new listings from January through October 2026, compared with 59 in the same months of 2025, and 9.7 months of supply. Those figures, the softer median and the island-wide pattern of below-asking closings all describe the same middle market. Buyers in that band have choices this winter, and sellers who priced to the market have been the ones closing quickly.
Edgartown's averages and record sales describe a top tier of village and waterfront homes bought largely with cash. The median, the 70-sale pace in the $1 million to $3 million band and the share of below-asking closings describe the homes most buyers are actually looking at. For a buyer comparing Edgartown with Oak Bluffs or West Tisbury, the second set of numbers is the one to use. The Edgartown neighborhood guide and our earlier look at Edgartown village versus Katama cover where each band sits on the ground.
Is Edgartown getting more expensive? At the top, yes. Sales above $10 million doubled from 2024 to 2025, In 2026 the town has already recorded the $43 million Great Point sale. The MAR single-family median for January through October 2026 was $2,412,500, 5.2 percent below the same period of 2025.
Where do Edgartown homes between $1 million and $3 million tend to sell? This fall's deeds put them along West Tisbury Road, Atwood Circle, Oyster Pond Road, Whalers Walk, Dodgers Hole Road, Kent Harbor Road, the inland end of Katama Point Road and Chappaquiddick Road. The historic village streets mostly sold above $3.5 million over the same months.
How long are Edgartown homes taking to sell? In the MAR single-family data for January through October 2026, the median was 78 days on market, down from 136 in the same months of 2025.
If you are weighing an Edgartown purchase this winter, or deciding which band your own home will compete in, The Agency Martha's Vineyard can walk you through the recent sales on your street and the ones like it. Request a Local Consultation, or start with a home valuation based on this fall's Edgartown deeds.
Stay up to date on the latest real estate trends.
We offer real estate services with heart. As a locally owned agency, we provide trusted guidance and personalized attention to help you navigate the Martha's Vineyard market.